Thanks Pipskateer, I think you misunderstand me a bit. I shouldn't call it a system perhaps. I am testing under the premise that there are absolutes that Skunny follows......instead of discretion. Skunny has convinced me that his method is the exact ...

Indicator Free Trading - Skunny

Biggest thing I notice on your charts and some others on here is that you've pulled your fibs from the bodies of candles rather then wicks. This may work to an extent also, but I am drawing my from the wicks as per Skunny. If I am trying to see what ...

Indicator Free Trading - Skunny

This is great comparing notes! I thought at first this was discretionary, but more and more I am convinced it is not? I'm not convinced I have it completely, just convinced that there must be a certain % of retrace on the same TF that would make ...

Indicator Free Trading - Skunny

Ok sizz, Slow down! hehe I just saw your 4th chart..........IMO the way this fib is drawn is wrong also......there is no retrace (to form a fibbable bottom).......so i think technically it could have failed the way you drew it. I agree with the ...

Indicator Free Trading - Skunny

Yes Sizz, Your charts accurately reflect what I am trying to say........ the EU and GU completed a 50 retrace......... but the UJ didn't quite retrace to the 23.6.......so technically not a valid trade on my theory. BUT it could be that a 23.6 ...

Indicator Free Trading - Skunny

I could be completely off base here but check this....... Did the fibs that worked have at least a certain level of retrace..........say 38.2 or 50 and you subconsiously recognized it? Did the fibs that didn't work, NOT have this level of retrace? ...

Indicator Free Trading - Skunny

Also something Skunny said waaaaay back after I posted a EurAud chart sticks in my mind. I had posted a small TF fib BEFORE there was a 38 retrace and it worked. BUT.........Skunny said something to the effect that price was too close to my 0 line ...

Indicator Free Trading - Skunny

Sadly, I cannot do any testing for at least another 10 days, when I am home at my computer. Don't think I better clutter up my father-in-laws computer with MT4, vhands and charts............lol. He thinks I'm nuts anyway. [/quote] hehehe Crikey... ...

Indicator Free Trading - Skunny

I like that line of thinking.. I know we both have been running not walking in circles trying to figure it out and I have mis fibbed my share.. oh sweet lord have I ever OK so Lowell test this out here is a "take it as it comes" GU chart as I ...

Indicator Free Trading - Skunny

My 2 pips: Penetration is penetration...........a valid trigger on any TF unless it is bad data (conflicting data from several platforms). These charts you've posted, (Post # 1923) illustrate the main problem I have run into while testing fibs. Some ...

Indicator Free Trading - Skunny

Since this is not an indicator, I'll post it here: GO COLTS!! P.S. - Packers survived only to die another day! EDIT: Ok, new fav team, GO PACKERS!!

Indicator Free Trading - Skunny

FXCM Ganns and fibs — Ok, please no one persecute me for posting this. If Skunny wants it off I will delete it. I just thought it extremely interesting that FXCM used a trend line and elliot waves that look a lot like a Gann line and fib ...

Indicator Free Trading - Skunny

Gonna, need a new pip trophy case I see! Awesome!

Indicator Free Trading - Skunny

I consider myself properly chastised!

Indicator Free Trading - Skunny

Hehe, nope! Found out my in-laws just got broadband. I'm glued to the monitor even though I'm 2,100 miles from home, lol. I hate to admit my own impatience but I am realizing its probably safer for me to have access to all this discussion/analysis ...

Indicator Free Trading - Skunny

Ok, I'm an idiot............ What do you mean by the last line, Skunny? "What is - Isn't" Are you saying there is really nothing discretionary about where to draw the fibs once we know all the rules? If so "Yippee"!!!!!!!

Indicator Free Trading - Skunny

In a word.......... — ABSOLUTELY!

Trading Workshop Possibility - Skunny & Bobokus

SKUNNY and all, I'm leaving for a 2 week vacation with my wife and kids. So won't be able to check in much (no laptop yet). I am completely loving everything that is happening here. I can not thank Skunny, Sizz, Blue and a ton of others enough. I am ...

Indicator Free Trading - Skunny

Check your pm's Skunny

Indicator Free Trading - Skunny

Blueruby, I was rereading the thread and came across this post and chart of yours from Dec. 30th. WOW, WOW, WOW!!! Just take a look at the 2 daily bars that have nailed the 138 short target of your yellow fib as of end of trading friday Jan. 4th!! ...

Indicator Free Trading - Skunny