Yeah, to be fair there was 134 positions opened and closed in that day, some were open for less than a minute so I can understand how that could potentially be difficult to replicate. Im not gonna pretend that I can understand that type of trading, ...

Prop Firm Hub

But how would the trader be aware if his/her trades could be replicated or not, after all we are supposed to be just retail traders, why should we have to know how their backend software works? Why do some firms accommodate this and some dont, and ...

Prop Firm Hub

Nice one mate, with other good opportunities to enter/scale in.

vsa with Malcolm

I merged them into a single PDF to make it easier mate. They are not in perfect order/layout though.

vsa with Malcolm

This looked like a good trade yesterday on the Dow. False break of the Asian lows, followed by an effort to rise bar taking out the OR high showing potential demand. No supply back into the OR high confirming the strength, and potential entry here. ...

vsa with Malcolm

........... yep, your probably right

FTMO - For serious traders

Congratulations mate. I know the case is closed and all that, but........ !!!!! I bet it feels good to ram-it up all the doubters!!!! "case officially closed now"

FTMO - For serious traders

Nice one mate, at least your getting some progress.

FTMO - For serious traders

Just to add something about lot size. GBPUSD, 3 pip stop loss on a 200k account. (One of those nice sniper entries that smart money style traders seem to like). 4% risk - well within the daily drawdown parameters and im very sure that this kind of ...

FTMO - For serious traders

4 massive and risky trades? He only had to make 5%. If those trading opportunities occured in one day then so what. And also like someone else pointed out, coasting through the minimum days using micro fillers is pretty much standard practice. You ...

FTMO - For serious traders

FWIW mate, your statements didnt come across as arguing to me. I would actually say that you replied respectully with facts and your wordings were bang on, it was the others that argued with you it seems.

Prop Firm Hub

Speaking of Nas, looks like there was a nice OR long on M15 with trend allignment on above timeframes. No testing on M15+ though so a bit more aggressive.

vsa with Malcolm

Sorry mate im not used to myfxbook, but is that an average of 3.5 pips per trade?, or 3.5 pips total over 12 trades?

Prop Firm Hub

Just want to say that personally for me (i dont know about anyone else) I dont mind guys like DylanE8 coming in here and throwing their neck on the chopping block to address an issue, because if they can come out on top with a solid argument then ...

Prop Firm Hub

Are we allowed to post any kind of commercial stuff here? Or is it only prop firms allowed?

Prop Firm Hub

Eh?? Are you saying that JotaP shouldnt be arguing his case, because what? They are a startup? Thats pathetic Ive also ran a business, and it was a startup aswell, did I make mistakes?, yes. But I had to pay for those mistakes the hard way and not ...

Prop Firm Hub

Oh Yeah! Cant wait to hear the answer to that.

Prop Firm Hub

Its cool mate, I will drop the banter down a peg or two and we can all get back to VSA tranquility

vsa with Malcolm

Like I said mate, the intention isnt to "bad mouth" anyone, I appreciate all of Toms, Gavin and everyones work. And I also think the software is class so no issues there. I might have the odd joke everynow and again and point out ironic observations ...

vsa with Malcolm

Yeah "necessary evil" was the wrong choice of words (sorry my vocabulary is limited) what I ment was that you just have to work around the sales stuff when watching the videos. Ive not got a problem with Gavin mate, I dont think anyone else has ...

vsa with Malcolm