The second one.

vsa with Malcolm

No worries and we all see things in our own way. That said even your chart tells me my short was good. That down bar on volume right before my ND closed below that trend line. Then a ND into the L of the trend line. Still says short for me.

vsa with Malcolm

When starting out keep it very simple. Each day only needs one zone. The previous days zone (1 zone on whatever the highest 1hr volume bar was) used as possible entry or as target. Today's zone (usually LO first and then changed to NYO). I don't ...

vsa with Malcolm

And today GBPUSD traded up from today's zone to the L of yesterday's zone (which interestingly enough wasn't any of the London or NY PA but that Asia session bar) where some sellers / profit taking was found.

vsa with Malcolm

When is a spring a spring SOS and when is a spring actually sellers filling and absorbing buy orders as a SOW? The result of all effort upwards yesterday leading up to my trade was followed by result of no continued higher prices and then ultimately ...

vsa with Malcolm

Trend on what TF? LO put in a LH on the day so we had at least the starting's of the LL, LH structure. Also as noted before for my intraday trading I trade zone to zone and don't care about "trend" in the common sense. The zones are my trend ...

vsa with Malcolm

Why? Because the bar made the lowest low of 3 touches of the same area on the 15min chart, closed near it's low, closed below the low of the LO zone and was followed immediately by a complete lack of demand. High volume down bar on relatively small ...

vsa with Malcolm

Yes that fits the rules and ended up as a nice move down right after to the days low.

vsa with Malcolm

Not at all.

vsa with Malcolm

I wouldn't say it's the best, just my simple interpretation. I honestly don't even trade "pure" VSA. I trade VSA style entries into my zones. My journal page 1 has some of the basics covered. I wish I had time to offer more but I don't so there ...

vsa with Malcolm

Hundreds of posts by me here at this thread and over at my journal. Others along the way have used the zones in their own way (Liam - KinsaleForex uses with PnF).

vsa with Malcolm

The green line was my short entry and has nothing to do with any bars (other than being below the low of my ND entry bar). I typically trade lower TF entries into 1hr highest volume zones for the current day and also use the previous day as entry ...

vsa with Malcolm

No other factors. My intraday trading is quite simple. I trade 1hr UHV zones (usually focusing on LO and NYO) and then trade entries into the levels of these zone (like a ND into the L). Sellers were in control on GBPUSD ever since that overnight ...

vsa with Malcolm

You have two high volume zones both controlled by sellers and then ND. That's all I need to be OK shorting. Sellers and no buyers = market going down. May only be temporary or a correction in a larger overall trend but that doesn't matter for me for ...

vsa with Malcolm

Hey Dara, how are things going for you? Glad you found something that works for you and how you like to trade. I for one got my ticket for the train ride. GBPUSD today for me I was only looking for short trades at the end of that first bar of the ...

vsa with Malcolm

VSA or Wyckoff trading doesn't need to be complicated. GBPUSD for example was clear today (as were several others). UHV mark-up overnight, LO was another SOW as we failed to close over mid point of the overnight bar. 15 min chart attached showing a ...

vsa with Malcolm

After a bunch of pointless meandering up, down and sideways GBPUSD is finally testing down into my line in the sand level... Will the bulls or bears take ownership. We shall see.

vsa with Malcolm

Friday was a lovely ND on GBPUSD daily chart just in time for the FBI to clear Clinton. Right at. 38.2 retrace of the move down that started in Sept if you follow that sort of thing. Wasn't that convenient? Watching my line in the sand level ...

vsa with Malcolm

Willing sellers on that bar for sure. Right now looking like buyers will absorb for more higher prices. Right now we are lingering around just below 50% of the Oct 3rd ultra WR / UHV bar (also near 2500) weekly bar. Yesterday was a big day for bulls ...

vsa with Malcolm

The hourly chart printed a lovely little test in the final hour before the news. It printed the lowest low since LO and down very close to the low for the day. Lowest volume since LO too so all in all a great test. I went in long (fueled by news) on ...

vsa with Malcolm